I get commission for purchases or clicks made through links in this post.
I used to wear dresses a lot. I had so many! Most of them were of the cheap-and-cheerful variety and all are long gone. Now I only have a few that are special (and rarely worn.) I still like them, but with the recent trend of ruffles and prairie crap I basically gave up looking for more.
And then I posted about my suitcase packing panic and my brain broke because I decided I need a casual, easy dress for this trip and I COULD NOT STOP until I found it. There was a bit of a obsessive online shopping spiral, which is a thing I do. In the end, I only ordered two dresses, both from Everlane: the The Rib-Knit Cap-Sleeve Midi Dress and the The Muscle Tee Midi Dress, both in black because I’m delightfully boring now.
I tried the muscle tee dress on first and automatically dismissed it because it dared to touch my stomach, the part of my body I dislike the most. Then I tried on the rib-knit dress and was like, huh, this is really nice but too long. Then I tried on both again, this time with shoes and accessories, and sent the photos to my friends because that’s how I do. First, the rib knit dress:
It skims nicely. A detail shot because it’s hard to photograph black clothing:
Y’all, this is such a nice dress. The material hangs beautifully and had a bit of weight to it but it doesn’t feel hot. It looks expensive! The color is not a true black, it leans a bit more charcoal and the rib knit gives it texture. My main issue is that midi length is so weird on me and I feel dowdy and stumpy, rather than elegant. I can’t wear heels right now (maybe not ever) and don’t have time to get it hemmed, so I was really on the fence. Now, the muscle sleeve dress:
This one is more body-con but has the edgy sleeves to give it interest and even though it’s midi length on me, the side slits break up the line. Overall, it’s a damn cool dress. It’s made of a nice medium-weight cotton so it’s more casual, but could easily be dressed up. My main negative, as I mentioned, was that it hugged my stomach a little bit and that is such a thing for me. But, it’s definitely the kind of dress I was looking for - easy and casual, perfect with Birks and good with sneakers:
I was pretty much a no on this one despite all it’s positives. But, here’s the punchline: I sent all these photos to three friends and all three of them, without fail, loved that muscle tee dress on me. I explained the stomach problem in detail and they all told me to kindly shut the fuck up and get over it. Per my friend Marianne: “You are a human with a stomach! You look great.” And the thing is, this dress is so exactly what I was looking for and I was quick to dismiss immediately it because of my own stupid hangup. Anyway, I kept it and returned the rib-knit dress without another thought. Sometimes a little peer pressure is all you need to get over yourself a little bit.
I am still working on the super tiresome aspect of some piece of clothing daring to cling to my midsection, but as I just said last week, I am really trying to get past the idea that everything I wear is somehow supposed to magically make me look smaller or more pleasingly shaped1. My body is fine the way it is and this is a great dress.
Is this a GenX thing? I feel like the younger folks today are more into dressing as they please and care less about “flattering.”
I love them both on you, too! I can't say whether it's a Gen X thing or not but I immediately looked at that second dress and thought, "I could never wear that because it would make my arms look huge." So, I have a "thing," too. I hope younger generations aren't as hung up as we are because it's an exhausting way to live.
Maybe it is a generational thing – my Gen Z kids and their friends don’t seem to have the same body issues that we had. But also, they don’t have my boomer mother hanging over them, going on a different crazy-ass diet every couple of weeks, criticizing the way their outfits look and asking if they don’t want to maybe go to aerobics with her [MEANINGFUL LOOK].
On another note, I like the idea of dresses, and I like them on other people, but on me, they sort of feel like grown-up lady cosplay. Pants and shorts for me, unless I’m going somewhere really formal – then I want to really dress up with a great dress and heels. But that’s like maybe twice a year. 🤷♀️